bursting shell

This problem was contributed to the Feynman Lectures Website by Sukumar Chandra.

A shell flying with velocity 500 m/s bursts into three identical fragments so that the kinetic energy of the system increases 1.5 times. What maximum velocity can one of the fragments obtain? .

Solution by Michael A. Gottlieb

From conservation of momentum we know that in the center of mass frame of the fragments the momentum of any fragment is equal and opposite to the sum of the momenta of the other two fragments, and since all fragments have the same mass, this must also hold for their velocities. Call their velocities U1, U2 and U3, with U3 being fastest. We have

(1)     U3 = (U1+ U2).

From conservation of energy we know that ˝m(|U1|2 + |U2|2 + |U3|2)  = E, where E is the total kinetic energy imparted to the fragments by the explosion and m is the mass of each fragment, so

(2)     |U3|2 = 2E/m (|U1|2 + |U2|2).

Writing (|U1|2 + |U2|2) as ˝(|U1+ U2|2 + |U1 U2|2) and using (1) we find,

(3)     |U3|2 = (4E/m |U1 U2|2)/3.

|U3| is maximal when |U1 U2| is minimal, which happens when U1= U2 = ˝U3.  Thus, in the CM frame the fastest fragment is moving in the direction opposite the other two fragments and twice as fast. Furthermore, U3 must be in the same direction as the shell's velocity V in the ground frame in order for their sum, the velocity of the fastest fragment in the ground frame, to have maximum magnitude. Thus, in the ground frame the fastest fragment is moving in the same direction that the shell was moving before it exploded.  Having observed these two points, the problem reduces to simple algebra: Let the speed of the shell in the ground frame be V = 500 m/s. Let |U3| = 2U, and |U1| = |U2|  = U. Noting that the speeds of the fragments in the ground frame are V+2U (fastest fragment) and VU (other two fragments), we can translate the given kinetic energy increase into,

(4)     3/2 * (1/2)(3m)V^2 = (1/2)(2m)(VU)^2 + (1/2)m(V+2U)^2,

which simplifies to V = 2U. Hence the speed of the fastest fragment is V + 2U = V + V = 1000 m/s.